If you are in the home buying process and wondering about
the cost effectiveness of buying a home warranty, you are not in a minority.
One of the most common questions we get from prospective homebuyers is “Should
I buy a home warranty plan?” Unlike some questions that can be answered with a
quick, decisive “yes” or “no,” this one takes a little more thought and
pondering.
To Buy or Not to Buy?
The short answer is you should make the decision about
purchasing a home warranty or any other type of insurance or warranty on your home purchased based on your personal circumstances and the advice of your real
estate professional. However, there are some general guidelines that we can
offer to help you in the decision making process.
What Is a Home Warranty?
A home warranty plan is a contract that provides for the
repair or replacement of certain items and/or mechanical systems on a
structure. These plans are usually issued for a one-year period and may or may
not be renewable at the end of the term.
While plans vary according to the
issuing company and any state or federal guidelines, they usually do not cover
loss or damage due to fire, disasters (think hurricanes or floods), or theft.
Most, but not all, newly constructed homes come with a one-year free warranty
plan. If you are considering making an offer on a new house, why not ask the seller to include a free home warranty? It never hurts to ask for a concession!
Typically, the plan covers major items such as heating and air-conditioning
systems, plumbing and major appliances. On an average, expect to pay about $300
to $600 for a one-year policy with an average deductible ranging from $50 to
$100. Keep in mind that for every person who makes a claim for around $6000, the
warranty company is predicting that there will be at least 10 people (if
not more) who will never need to make a claim.
Like most warranties, contracts vary from state to state and even from company
to company so you must do your due diligence so you know the specific
limitations, coverages, and restrictions that apply to your situation. Read
the contract completely and ask for clarification of any terminology or jargon
you do not understand. Let’s take a quick look at the pros and cons of home
warranty plans.
Advantages
Here are some common pros of this type of coverage:
- Knowing that you are covered for defects and mechanical problems is reassuring.
- Even if you possess the skill and necessary equipment to make major repairs such as replacing a heating or air conditioning system, you may prefer the convenience of having it done for you. In addition, your time is typically better-spent working at whatever your profession is than in performing handy man home repairs.
- The cost of any repairs could be less expensive under a home warranty plan than trying to do them yourself or paying a professional.
- If you are purchasing an older home, there could be a greater likelihood of incurring a big-ticket repair because of the age of the home, mechanical systems, and appliances. Purchasing a warranty might outweigh the costs of repairs or replacements of these high dollar items.
- While there are never any guarantees, if you have a home inspection done prior to making your purchase offer, potential problems areas could be identified. Knowing in advance that there could be a problem within the first year of your ownership makes it easier to make your final decision.
Disadvantages
In our opinion, the biggest disadvantage is the fact that if
you never need the policy, you have wasted your one-year premium. Would you be
better off if you simply set aside an equivalent amount of money for repairs? Here are some other drawbacks to ponder:
- Home warranties provide short-term coverage. If you are purchasing an older home, the cost of the warranty may or may not be justified, but if you are purchasing a relatively newly constructed home, the odds of needing the coverage are dramatically reduced.
- The warranty company makes the decision about replacing or repairing the item in question, not you. They may opt for the cheapest solution, which might not be the best overall solution for you.
- You have to use a service provider that is approved by the warranty holder; you cannot make your own choices about who will mitigate your problem.
- What will you do if your claim is denied? Will you have the time to invest in appealing the denial and trying to get your problem resolved?
What’s the Bottom Line
Home warranties may be a good answer in some situations but
they are certainly not a “one size fits all” solution to some common
problems of home ownership such as costly repairs. Consult with your real estate agent and consider factors such as:
- Annual cost
- Extent of coverage’s
- Deductible
- Additional fees if applicable
- Restrictions and exclusions
Weighing all these factors against the return on investment
helps you make the best choice as to whether you should buy a home warranty or
pass on it. For the most part, the bottom line is the most a home warranty can do for you is limit your risk (for one year only) of having to deal with a major expense which was not apparent at the time of closing.
Do you have other questions about the home buying process? You can find answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about buying a home by purchasing a copy of our latest book Buying Your First Home? Insider Secrets You Must Know or by browsing the archive files for more information on hot topics.
Be sure to leave us a note in the comments section and share your input on the feasibility of buying a warranty on a home purchase.
Image: Free Digital Photos by Basketman, used under license
What Do You Think? Are Home Warranties a Good or Bad Idea?
Be sure to leave us a note in the comments section and share your input on the feasibility of buying a warranty on a home purchase.
Image: Free Digital Photos by Basketman, used under license











